Hart - sell or loan?

Rumours are that Hart will either leave for Everton or Liverpool or he might go on loan to Sevilla with the hope that he can improve his passing skills and get back in at City.

The latter option really depends on what Pep has said to him. If he's given him hope, he may take this option as he loves City and they City will probably win the most silverware in the next few years.

He may just be so pissed off, or Pep has told him there is no chance in the future, that a sale is inevitable.

Keep him and don't buy Bravo...simples.

Other than that.....sell him, i'm not one for loaning any players out. I'm sick of us never being able to get loan players in, we have to pay over the odds to get anyone.

shakencity wrote:Keep him and don't buy Bravo...simples.

^^^^ This.

I don't care how bad he may be with his feet, there is no way on this earth that either Willy or Bravo is even close to little Joe in terms of quality.  But yeah, let's just sell our best players, chuck the baby out with the bath water... 

agreed also..

what they said ^^^^^^

But on the plus side, he's been with us for ten years, so if he does go, at least he'll get a testimonial without everyone having to sign a bloody petition!

I don't think he'll want one anytime soon.

Just been talking to Dawg on email about Joe.....

My son works at The Cheshire Ice Cream Farm down the road from us. Joe's just been there and they said he was a top bloke. Will asked him to stay - he just shrugged his shoulders and said "cheers mate"

Will next to him in the glasses....he's still there he said.

I feel sorry for Joe now.  He's not the best in the world but he's been a positive influence at the club all these years.  Shame.

Walter's always good value

If any player epitomises Manchester City it's Joe Hart. he's probably the one player that most City fans hold up as what being  a player for us should mean. Shame to see him go like this.

Just shows you how full of shit some journos are, as one of them is bullshitting...

The Sun...a high up insider claims City will only sell, not loan Joe Hart for over £30m

The MEN...a close source at Man City claim City aren't thinking of selling him.

And Barca claim Bravo will play tomorrow.

I wonder what the chances of Little Joe starting at Stoke are?

If he did, i wonder if he'll get a bigger cheer when his name's read out than Serge does

If Joe was to play against Stoke (and he won't) then you'd hear the cheers back in Manchester.

Wensdi wrote:I feel sorry for Joe now.  He's not the best in the world but he's been a positive influence at the club all these years.  Shame.

Exactly!

Topdawg wrote:Walter's always good value

He is.  One of our best signings in recent years, I'd say!

Topdawg wrote:If any player epitomises Manchester City it's Joe Hart. he's probably the one player that most City fans hold up as what being  a player for us should mean. Shame to see him go like this.

Yes, him and Zaba, they are the ones who play like they are fans lucky enough to get to pull on the shirt.

leopold wrote:

Topdawg wrote:If any player epitomises Manchester City it's Joe Hart. he's probably the one player that most City fans hold up as what being  a player for us should mean. Shame to see him go like this.

Yes, him and Zaba, they are the ones who play like they are fans lucky enough to get to pull on the shirt.

I'd put Vinny and to a certain extent Serge in that list too.

Yes to Vinny. Serge, possibly less so. I think we love him because he's an incredible talent rather than a dyed in the wool blue.

Peps presser was very cryptic,,
essentially saying Hart will improve if he stays and will adapt and get game time..

also says if Hart wants to leave he can do, but if he wants to stay they will fight together..